« Climate section pagePromotional content

Aug 02 2018. 09 29 PM Thu

‘Some stresses on biodiversity being downplayed’

There is a need to find ways to make urbanisation, linear intrusions and biodiversity coexist, say panellists at 'Danfoss-Mint Transformation Agenda'

(From left) Utpal Bhaskar, energy editor, Mint; J. Srinivasan, distinguished scientist, Divecha Centre for Climate Change; Jagdish Krishnaswamy, senior fellow, Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment; Aromar Revi, director, Indian Institute for Human Settlements; and Ulka Kelkar, senior climate policy lead, World Resources Institute India, at the Danfoss-Mint Transformation Agenda 2020 in Bengaluru. Photo: Jithendra M./Mint

Bengaluru: The panel discussion on climate imperatives, moderated by Mint’s energy editor Utpal Bhaskar, included J. Srinivasan, distinguished scientist, Divecha Centre for Climate Change; Jagdish Krishnaswamy, senior fellow, Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment; Aromar Revi, director, Indian Institute for Human Settlements; and Ulka Kelkar, senior climate policy lead, World Resources Institute India. Edited excerpts:

What are your views on the conundrum between environmental issues and growth?

Krishnaswamy: The reason why I mention land transformation metrics as an important lens is not because climate change is going to add a lot of stress and some of what it is likely to do is very uncertain right now—it might even destroy an ecosystem. But the other stresses on our biodiversity and ecosystems are sometimes downplayed.

If you ask any conservationist who works at the local or regional scales about threats to aquatic biodiversity in India or threats to some of our large mammals, climate change will not immediately come to mind. There are other stresses in terms of overexploitation of the species, or transformation of habitats—those are processes that we have to manage if we have to adapt, if these ecosystems have to adapt and novel ecosystems have to emerge where we have new types of livelihood and economic opportunities. It’s in that light we should not forget about other stresses.

Whatever we have done to our forests and rivers have been because of these other stresses and not climate change, as of now. We are seeing certain types of transformation that we have to manage. India is getting urbanised a lot. How do you manage biodiversity, especially biodiversity that needs to move from one patch of forest to another, when you have highways and towns mushrooming? We need to think about how urbanisation, linear intrusions and biodiversity can coexist, and it will have to be a combination of land sharing and land sparing approaches at multiple scales. If done smartly, that can potentially generate a lot of jobs.

Kelkar: There is a lot of faith in specific technological solutions but that is only a piece of the puzzle. The story is much larger—these technological solutions are embedded in a larger governance landscape and that is part of a culture or a lifestyle in itself. There is much to be said about leaving it to the community, decentralisation for example, but that alone will not take care of the issue. The important part is larger policy support, capital and know-how. Otherwise, that connection between what’s happening at the grass-roots scale and the larger scale won’t happen.

The second point is about behavioural changes. At a conference recently, somebody said a builder doesn’t just sell a building, he sells you a lifestyle. So how are we appreciating or understanding the aspirations of people and how they are changing. People are willing to go in for renewable energy when they purchase a new home. That’s where you can actually make a change.

How has Bengaluru coped with urbanisation?

Revi: Bengaluru is struggling. We are talking a lot about temperature and that’s because climate change has been looked at from a temperate climate point of view, where temperatures are a critical thing. But for India the critical issue is water, and Bengaluru is struggling and will continue to struggle on water. The really interesting thing that may happen is if we are able to transform our water management for the city. The city itself cannot do it. It has to be handled regionally and as Ulka is saying, it has to start really at the lifestyle end of things. We have to be able to bring down water consumption to 70 litres per capita and reduce inequality across the city because half the city is currently being fed by tankers. If Bengaluru is able to crack that problem, it is going to grow and develop.

The Metro is a beginning for that because one very clear thing we know for cities across the world is you need to shrink footprints. Bengaluru is like a doughnut. The centre of the city is very low in density and outside the city is growing very rapidly, and it doesn’t work for us. We have to move to a more livable, walkable city.

What are your views on India’s power sector situation and reforms?

Srinivasan: Increasing cooling load will generate more heat—that statement is true but what people don’t realize is the amount of waste the industry (generates) today is 1/100th of the amount of heat trapped by carbon dioxide.

Carbon dioxide trapping heat cannot be seen so none of us are aware of it. One has to focus on controlling carbon dioxide because that’s much bigger than the waste heat problem. I think coal is a curse for India for two reasons—it is of low quality and it is under the forest floor, and we are removing forests to get coal. We should have not gone towards coal but towards solar after independence.

India is extremely dependent on the monsoon and there is already a farm distress in the country. What happens now?

Revi: The fact is even at one point of time, 50% of our species, plant or others, are going to see a 50% reduction in their range. We have never seen this since the beginning of our agricultural revolution, around 10,000 years ago. Growing things in areas that are completely unviable ecologically and increasing now economically, and simultaneously, now we have a health crisis, the public distribution system has given us a lot of nice things and food security but it is creating a huge epidemic as far as lifestyle diseases are concerned. We have to radically re-examine this.

Krishnaswamy: 150 years ago, people did not eat potatoes. It is possible for changes in diet but it’s not going to happen overnight. In the Indo-Gangetic plains, even a 10% reduction in water use in agriculture, can put back enough water in some of our rivers to allow the aquatic biodiversity to thrive and to help downstream artisanal fisheries to survive. These are opportunities for creation of new jobs and skills which are linked to a transformation that we need for adapting to the future.

Kelkar: We have to look at food and diet in perspective of a farmer. Because a farmer only grows what he/she can sell, not just the question of price but also of convenience. If the demand or market does not exist, then you have to create the market and the entire support system. We must also look at some of these larger policy issues from the perspective of an individual.

Is the US walking out of the Paris climate deal an ideal time for India and China to collaborate?

Krishnaswamy: We have a shared security regime, what happens to Tibetan plateau and the catchment of the Brahmaputra is something that India and China need to work together. And also there are planned transformations of the river systems that pose, in some sense, national security concerns. We have been planning many projects thinking that these are stationary systems. The monsoon itself is a big variable. National, water, biodiversity and ecological security is as important as the security emanating from guns and bombs.

Revi: This is not the question of just India, China or the US but all humanity. Irrespective of what the other country does, the impacts are going to be felt across the world, especially in countries that have large populations. Food security is a very critical question we share as far as that is concerned. We can’t underestimate the Chinese ability to turn this to their advantage. We have to be pragmatic like China is on mutual interest.

Srinivasan: No one seems to be addressing the elephant in the room; it’s population. We are going to add 500 million people. I don’t see how we can avoid ecological stress. So we have to learn from China how to control our population.


Jun 21 2018. 11 46 PM Thu

'Smart cities are not only about sensors and gadgets but also mobility, development, jobs'

There is no one-size-fits-all solution to challenges cities face today, said panellists at the 'Danfoss-Mint Transformation Agenda...

Jun 21 2018. 11 15 PM Thu

India's future lies in creating carbon-neutral cities, says Danfoss India's Purushothaman

With the fast pace of urbanization across India and the world, adopting carbon-neutral technologies and offering innovative solutions...

Jun 06 2018. 10 44 AM Wed

How new-age infrastructure projects are redefining India

The rising aspirations and needs of citizens are driving India towards new-age infrastructure where "SMART" is the byword. Almost every new infra project, be it...

Jun 06 2018. 10 43 AM

My dream is that people will soon zoom on smart highways: Nitin Gadkari

Nitin Gadkari, minister for road transport and highways, said his dream project of smart highways is progressing in the right direction. Smart roads...

Jun 05 2018. 06 38 PM

Inclusive agenda key win for smart cities programme

The project cost for all cities put together is ₹2.02 trillion, split into area-based development projects costing ₹1.63 trillion, and pan-city solutions projects...

May 30 2018. 01 05 AM

India turns hot spot for global firms offering smart mobility

India's quest for smart mobility has made the country a hot spot for international companies to offer their latest technologies such as pod taxis, hyperloop, electric...

May 21 2018. 12 48 PM

Organized supply chain, growing crops in sync with demand can boost farmers' incomes

Growing crops in sync with market demand can boost farmers' income, while organized supply chain can reduce loss of...

May 09 2018. 10 08 PM

Govt creating infra to reduce food waste, says Harsimrat Badal

Food processing minister Harsimrat Kaur Badal said the government is working to reduce wastage of food by creating a cold chain grid across the country...

May 02 2018. 09 09 PM

Making India's fruit processing industry globally competitive

India is the second largest country in terms of arable land, roughly 160 million hectares. It also ranks second in production of fruits and vegetables. India has 15...

May 02 2018. 09 00 PM

Food safety policies need to cover the entire chain, from farm to fork

India is one of the leading producers of food globally and there is a lot of potential which can be harnessed to create a safe and healthy food ecosystem in the country...

May 02 2018. 08 17 PM

Organic food market to grow at 20-25%: 24 Mantra Organic CEO

Organic produce is an emerging market in India, clocking a turnover of Rs3,350 crore in 2016, and is expected to treble it by 2020. According to N. Balasubramanian...

Apr 25 2018. 10 04 AM

Food safety needs a collaborative approach

Our country, though agriculturally abundant, is still struggling to provide its large population with the right nutrition. In a few decades, as we continue to grow in numbers and economically...

Apr 25 2018. 09 50 AM

Can there be a viable value chain for fresh fruits and vegetables?

India has seen large investments in supply chain of apple by way of controlled atmosphere cold stores in which oxygen levels are reduced from about 21% to 2% and...

Apr 25 2018. 09 43 AM

Will food processing boost prices for farmers?

Last month, Premsingh Chavan, a farmer from Maharashtra's Marathwada region, destroyed his ready-to-harvest crop of tomatoes and cauliflowers after wholesale prices...

Mar 30 2018. 03 11 AM

Policies, institutions, bureaucracy key to energy efficiency mission'

'Energy saved is energy gained' should be the mantra for India's evolving energy paradigm, said experts at Mint Danfoss Transformation agenda on energy...

Mar 12 2018. 12 51 AM

We are preparing a national strategic plan for energy efficiency: BEE's Abhay Bakre

State-backed Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) is leading the government's efforts to set energy efficiency benchmarks and to have...

Mar 12 2018. 01 41 AM

Achieving energy efficiency key to meeting lower emissions commitment

It is important to educate consumers and spread awareness of various energy efficient options in the market that can help in optimizing...

Feb 28 2018. 06:38 AM

Getting around India's energy efficiency conundrum

The road towards energy efficiency hasn't been easy due to lack of funds, resulting in the govt rolling out a number of policies that include a market-based trading mechanism...

Feb 28 2018. 12:19 AM

The road ahead: charting own path while learning from global experience

Rapid industrialization and growing population are increasingly changing the ecology of the planet. With all the increment in population and development, there are growing...


Energy efficiency is the new source of energy

The whole world may be looking to find the next best source of energy, so we can reduce the dependence on fossil fuel, and generate environment-friendly energy. But do you know that one of the largest sources of energy may just be energy efficiency?...


Raising the bar for a greener tomorrow

Rapid industrialization and growing population are increasingly changing the ecology of the planet. With all the increment in population and development, there are growing concerns of greenhouse gas emissions depleting green cover and causing global...


How an efficient cold chain is the answer to food losses and doubling farmers' income?

India is the world's second largest producer of fruits and vegetables, but also accounts for one of the biggest food loss and waste with harvest and post-harvest losses in fruits, vegetables, and grains worth...


Govt looks at energy-efficient ways to tackle climate change

The National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government has embarked on a multi-pronged strategy for achieving its climate change commitments, with measures ranging from combating air and water pollution to global...


India needs to do more to reduce carbon emissions

India is among the fastest growing economies and the third largest emitting country in the world, but has always held the onus of climate change on developed countries for their historical emissions. If it is the responsibility of every country to protect its...


As temperatures rise, nearly half of South Asia's population at risk

Average temperatures have risen over the past six decades and continue to do so in South Asia, making it, particularly India, where 75% of the population is dependent on agriculture, one of the regions most vulnerable to climate...


Average sea levels may rise by up to 30 ft on global warming, says study

Average sea levels may rise by up to 30 feet around the world if humans continue to burn fossil and fuels causing temperatures to breach the threshold of 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial...


The need to invest more on climate change education

Nearly half of the population in India lives in places that are likely to become moderate or severe climate hot spots by 2050, according to a World Bank Study launched very recently. Changing rainfall pattern due to climate change could result...


Cities seen taking more eco-friendly steps to become climate resilient

When Ahmedabad became the first city in South Asia to develop a heat action plan in 2013, the initiative snowballed into a national effort involving 30 other cities. Several of them also appointed a resilience officer for the first...


'Some stresses on biodiversity being downplayed'

The panel discussion on climate imperatives, moderated by Mint's energy editor Utpal Bhaskar, included J. Srinivasan, distinguished scientist, Divecha Centre for Climate Change...


There is an opportunity for Delhi and Beijing to work together on climate agenda, says ICRIER's Kathuria

While climate change and environment, and urbanization are focus areas in the economic policy making in India...


India can become powerhouse for clean tech: Danfoss' Ravichandran Purushothaman

Climate change presents a great opportunity for India that, coupled with 'Make in India', can help the country become a global powerhouse for clean technologies...

The above content has not been created by any Mint journalist or editorial teams